AND Magazine homepage
Editorial » Fashion » Women
TOP EDITORIAL THIS HOUR:
A Model Acid-Burned
Features: Katie Piper: My life was so superficial. - Model Katie Piper had acid th... By AND Staff
A New Internet
Publishers Stream: The U.S. Internet, by virtue of its adherence civil liberties, is more like the wild...
Gadhafi Threatens Europe Attacks Gadhafi Threatens Europe Attacks
...homes, offices, families... - The Libyan leader, sought by... - Reprint from AP
TODAY'S COVER STORY:
Happy Halloween Happy Halloween Villafane: Pumpkin Carving Extraordinaire
TOP RECOMMENDATIONS THIS HOUR:
FashionWire™.
Mary J and Halle

Mary J and Halle
Mary J and Halle

Mary J Blige and Halle Berry attend the 2011 FiFi Awards at The Tent at Lincoln Center on May 25, 2011 in NYC.
THE LATEST EDITORIAL:
Politics and the English Language- George Orwell, 1946  - By Vincent Ferraro Politics and the English Language
The Independent: George Orwell, 1946 by Vincent Ferraro
The Vice Presidency- A hilarious, informative look at the Vice Presidents - By Anthony Bergen The Vice Presidency
Literature: A hilarious, informative look at the Vice Presidents by Anthony Bergen
The Bang Bang Club- Photographing the horrors of conflict - By Tom Cohen The Bang Bang Club
Entertainment: Photographing the horrors of conflict by Tom Cohen
A Time To Lead- President Obama enters budget fray - By Tom Glegola A Time To Lead
The Independent: President Obama enters budget fray by Tom Glegola
Madeline Zima- She packs a powerful punch - By Julia Gleason Madeline Zima
People: She packs a powerful punch by Julia Gleason
Big Feast at Tiffanys- Fib Newtons Gilded Age Redux - By Joseph Baron Pravda Big Feast at Tiffanys
The Left: Fib Newtons Gilded Age Redux by Joseph Baron Pravda
Burial At Sea- The Odyssey of JFK's Original Casket - By Anthony Bergen Burial At Sea
Features: The Odyssey of JFK's Original Casket by Anthony Bergen
Pants vs. Skirts- Who is Better Presidential Material - By Jill Jankoski Pants vs. Skirts
The Right: Who is Better Presidential Material by Jill Jankoski
Wait for the Damn Warrant- Three cases of a tragic, warrant-less act - By Aaron Stipkovich Wait for the Damn Warrant
USCS: Three cases of a tragic, warrant-less act by Aaron Stipkovich
Cinema Verite: Full of Naïveté- The first reality documentary - By Cassie Jordan Cinema Verite: Full of Naïveté
Entertainment: The first reality documentary by Cassie Jordan
Republicans for President- What I heard - By Brad Lockwood Republicans for President
The Independent: What I heard by Brad Lockwood
Isabella Rossellini- Portrait of an Innovative Woman - By Melanie Dameron Isabella Rossellini
People: Portrait of an Innovative Woman by Melanie Dameron
All The Austerity You Can Handle- Bringing The Government Back To Reality - By Robert Cleveland All The Austerity You Can Handle
The Right: Bringing The Government Back To Reality by Robert Cleveland
The Many Lives of Gwyneth Paltrow- The Real Renaissance Woman - By Meagan Lopez The Many Lives of Gwyneth Paltrow
People: The Real Renaissance Woman by Meagan Lopez
Disabling America- One Billion Can Not Be Wrong - By Brad Lockwood Disabling America
The Independent: One Billion Can Not Be Wrong by Brad Lockwood
Routine Emergencies- Their Tendency to Reemerge - By Joseph Baron Pravda Routine Emergencies
Features: Their Tendency to Reemerge by Joseph Baron Pravda
Penelope Cruz- A Girl with the High-heeled Sunday Look - By Joseph Baron Pravda Penelope Cruz
Entertainment: A Girl with the High-heeled Sunday Look by Joseph Baron Pravda
Les Paul- June 9, 1915 – August 12, 2009 - By Richard S. Ginell Les Paul
Music: June 9, 1915 – August 12, 2009 by Richard S. Ginell
Just Another Business- Reporting the news - By Tom Glegola Just Another Business
The Independent: Reporting the news by Tom Glegola
Advice for a Weiner- Pot Kettle Black Much  - By Jill Jankoski Advice for a Weiner
The Right: Pot Kettle Black Much by Jill Jankoski
Rachel Weisz- Artistic Dimensions of a Storyteller - By Melanie Dameron Rachel Weisz
People: Artistic Dimensions of a Storyteller by Melanie Dameron
Tolerance Among Trailers- Musings on man - By Sinclair Cohen Tolerance Among Trailers
The Left: Musings on man by Sinclair Cohen
The Forgotten Conflict- Remembering What War Means - By Hugo Delgado The Forgotten Conflict
The Right: Remembering What War Means by Hugo Delgado
Unfinished- The final days of Franklin Delano Roosevelt - By Anthony Bergen Unfinished
Literature: The final days of Franklin Delano Roosevelt by Anthony Bergen
A Fading Star- How FDR covered up the illness which likely killed him. - By Anthony Bergen A Fading Star
Literature: How FDR covered up the illness which likely killed him. by Anthony Bergen
Pop Culture Critics Unraveled Author Profile: Ashley GoldsmithBy Ashley Goldsmith, AND Magazine Columnist
Post Comments | More Ashley | Fashion | Power | FashionWire | Critics
Pop Culture Critics Unraveled
As told by a fashion columnist

Fashion critic Richard Blackwell, next to a photo of Victoria Beckham who he named the worst dressed of all time, just before his death in 2008.
Fashion critic Richard Blackwell, next to a photo of Victoria Beckham who he named the worst dressed of all time, just before his death in 2008.
While celebrities may have cringed at the announcement of Richard Blackwell’s annual “Ten Worst Dressed Women” list, fashionistas across the country waited with bated breath to hear his snarky and amusing analysis of the wardrobes of famous females.

While Blackwell’s resume includes 30 years of fashion design for his eponymous line, Mr. Blackwell, we’re still wondering what really qualified him to critique Hollywood’s elite for 48 years.

As styles evolve, past trends resurface and Lady Gaga fastens her hair bow, fashions finest critics are always there to point out when the fashionable and the not so fashionable have hit their marks, but most importantly when they’ve gone off the deep end.

The infamous worst dressed list came to an end after Blackwell's passing in 2008. But television hasn't given up on criticizing wardrobes, thanks to makeover shows and tabloid magazines. Oh, and if you're not careful, what you're wearing could be a poor reflection of who you are as a person.

Joan Rivers
Joan Rivers
Take Joan Rivers for example, a woman in her seventies with more Botox in her face than anyone should be legally allowed to have, has made a name for herself as a force to be reckoned with on the red carpet as the host of E! Networks Fashion Police. If you're caught in something too "safe" she'll have something to say about it. Too over-the-top? You'll never hear the end of it. So next time your shopping for an Oscar-worthy gown, be sure it's just right, as the goal is to be the least talked about when the best and worst dressed lists make their rounds.

What qualifies Ms. Rivers to critique red carpet dwellers, you ask? After hours of research, we’ve learned that aside from years of experience in show business, writing for The Tonight Show when Johnny Carson was hosting it and appearing in endless comedy shows; River’s hasn’t worked a day in the fashion world.

Could her shtick just be for comedic effect and dare I say…ratings? Surely, Rivers’ is part of the red carpet fashion police because of her outrageous commentary that just borderlines offensive. Or maybe America is entertained by the juxtaposition between her over-the-top appearance and the idea of someone like her judging how anyone else looks.

Blackwell’s worst dressed lists were always full of humor, using techniques like alliteration or free verse in some, while even making a pun about Queen Elizabeth, after nominating her as a fashion offender. “Was she the palace Christmas tree, or just a royal clown?” he quipped.

Steven Cojocaru
Steven Cojocaru
Enter Steven Cojocaru, best know for his role as Entertainment Tonight’s celebrity fashion correspondent. While his personal style picks are usually spot on (though, who are we to judge?), he looks like the love child of Rachel Zoe and Mick Jagger. With Botox injections headed for Joan Rivers-land, veneers that rival Hilary Duff’s and over processed, over-straightened hair teetering towards Britney Spears-ville (pre- and post-head shaving).

His resume however, because looks really shouldn’t matter, features a string of jobs as a fashion columnist, from his homeland of Canada to Hollywood, California. Does a fashion background justify harsh criticisms on and off the red carpet?

Just when you thought you were safe at home among friends and family, you’ll soon realize that they’re not to be trusted either, for they'll stab you in the back by nominating you to face TLC's go-to fashion guru's Stacy London & Clinton Kelly. While it may seem like What Not to Wear is an innocent attempt at helping fashion victims develop a wardrobe that's age-appropriate and fits properly, it's more like target practice for the two established fashion consultants. Don’t let the TLC network name fool you.

The shows 360-degree mirror allows participants to show-off a typical outfit of theirs and defend why they wear it. The stylists then pin point all the areas where their victim has gone wrong and ultimately force various styles of replacement outfits on them. As each episode progresses, the audience is shown that self esteem starts with an overpriced but well selected wardrobe.

Or maybe it’s purely for an ego boost? Let’s break down these larger than life celebrities, bring them to our level and show that they’re perfectly capable of making unforgivable fashion choices that we’ll never let them forget. Or how about a good old fashioned, putting someone else down to feel better about yourself? Exhibit A; the innocent victims who choose to accept the What Not to Wear challenge. We lounge around in the privacy of our own home in sweatpants and a stained college t-shirt, noshing on Sun Chips, dumbfounded by what an ordinary woman chooses to dress herself in everyday.

Tyra Banks
Tyra Banks
Take Tyra Banks’ infamous modeling show, America’s Next Top Model, now entering its 15th cycle. Chock-full of a group of under-fed 20 something’s, hoping that a chance to model for Tyra could be their next big break. While the contestants are chosen purely based on appearance, this is a modeling competition after all, one of their first experiences with Tyra is a total overhaul of their typical look; specifically targeting their hair.

Madness ensues as Tyra has colorists dying beautiful chestnut locks into bleached straw-like tresses, gluing in extensions and in some instances nearly shaving a contestant’s head. So while the main focus of the show is already all about appearance, the dozen mere mortals that have been chosen to compete, simply aren’t good enough and without Tyra’s help, they’ll never make it in the modeling world.

While Banks has the modeling chops to teach her budding cat walkers a thing or two, the underlying message of the show isn’t one of female empowerment as Banks promises, but just another way for American’s to criticize a few more poor, unfortunate souls, but this time they’re prettier than you.

Which brings us to the conclusion of our pop-culture critic critique. While their assessments may be harsh and in most cases embarrassing, given the level of people they’re reaching, maybe we all shouldn’t be so sensitive about it. After all, have you checked yourself out the mirror today?

Your Comments:

The AND Archives
Features

The AND Archives | We Keep Everything | Do not call us pack rats... but we are. | Wed,  1 Jun 2011 | Aaron Stipkovich | archives, old articles
We Keep Everything
Manuel Bolano
Feature

Manuel Bolano
A model presents a creation from designer Manuel Bolano at the 080 Barcelona Fashion Week o...
Energy Whores Inc.
The Independent

Energy Whores Inc. | I love that smell of emissions! | IÂ’m sure the widows of those dead coalminers appreciate such government oversight. | Wed,  1 Jun 2011 | Brad Lockwood | Bigfoot Massey
I love that smell of emissions!
"Pop Culture Critics Unraveled | As told by a fashion columnist" | Document 4009 published: Tue, 3 Aug 2010 | Sponsored by
Editorial » Fashion » Women options : Email This | Keywords: fashion critics
AND Magazine ™ © 2008-2011 | | A New Internet